Our gut sense of chance relies on mental shortcuts, such as the representativeness heuristic, which judges an event as likely when it looks like our mental picture of that event. This is why people often see a random sequence of coin flips as needing to "balance out," or treat a streak of heads as a sign that tails is overdue, even though each flip is independent.
Availability also distorts judgment: events that are vivid, recent, or easy to recall, like plane crashes or shark attacks, feel more common than they really are. Researchers Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky documented these patterns in the 1970s, showing that the errors are systematic rather than random, so they tend to recur even among people who understand the math.